seb/hermes-agent
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

fix(docker): make s6 lifecycle work for the unprivileged hermes user

Browse Source 
Resolves the explicit "Known follow-up" left by commit 2f8ceeab9 and
the resulting CI failures in tests/docker/test_dashboard.py and
tests/docker/test_s6_profile_gateway_integration.py.

The product gap
---------------
Every hermes runtime operation inside the container runs as the
hermes user (UID 10000) via s6-setuidgid. But s6-supervise — spawned
by s6-svscan running as PID 1 — creates each service's supervise/
and top-level event/ directories with mode 0700 owned by its
effective UID (root). That left every s6-svc / s6-svstat / s6-svwait
call from hermes hitting EACCES on the supervise/control FIFO and
supervise/status — i.e. the entire S6ServiceManager lifecycle
(register, start, stop, unregister) was inert in production.

The 2f8ceeab9 commit message called this out and deferred the fix.
The audit changes that landed alongside it (defaulting docker_exec
to -u hermes) made the integration tests reproduce the bug
deterministically; the fix below resolves it.

The fix: pre-create the supervise/ skeleton hermes-owned
----------------------------------------------------------
Reading s6's source (src/supervision/s6-supervise.c::trymkdir +
control_init), the mkdir and mkfifo calls that build the supervise
tree are EEXIST-safe: if the directory or FIFO is already present,
s6-supervise reuses it and skips the chown/chmod fix-up that would
normally make event/ 03730 root:root. So if we lay the skeleton
down with hermes ownership before triggering s6-svscanctl -a,
s6-supervise inherits our layout and never touches it. The
death_tally / lock / status regular files written later by
s6-supervise (still as root) land mode 0644 — world-readable —
which is all s6-svstat needs.

New module-level helper _seed_supervise_skeleton(svc_dir) in
hermes_cli/service_manager.py lays down:
  svc_dir/event/                       hermes:hermes 03730
  svc_dir/supervise/                   hermes:hermes 0755
  svc_dir/supervise/event/             hermes:hermes 03730
  svc_dir/supervise/control            hermes:hermes 0660 (FIFO)
  svc_dir/log/event/                   hermes:hermes 03730  (if log/ present)
  svc_dir/log/supervise/               hermes:hermes 0755
  svc_dir/log/supervise/event/         hermes:hermes 03730
  svc_dir/log/supervise/control        hermes:hermes 0660 (FIFO)

The log/ branch matters because the logger is a second
s6-supervise instance — without it, unregister rmtree races on
the logger's root-owned supervise dir even after the parent
slot's supervise/ is hermes-owned. The helper is idempotent and
swallows PermissionError on chown so it works equally well when
called from root (cont-init.d) or hermes (runtime register).

Wiring
------
1. S6ServiceManager.register_profile_gateway calls
   _seed_supervise_skeleton(tmp_dir) just before publishing the
   slot via Path.replace. Runtime-registered profile gateways are
   set up by hermes.

2. container_boot._register_service does the same in the cont-init.d
   reconciliation path so boot-time-restored profile slots inherit
   the same layout.

3. New cont-init.d/015-supervise-perms script chowns the supervise/
   and event/ trees for STATIC s6-rc services (dashboard,
   main-hermes). These are spawned by s6-rc before cont-init.d
   gets to run, so the EEXIST-trick doesn't apply; we chown the
   already-existing tree instead. s6-supervise keeps using the
   same files; it never re-asserts ownership on a running service.
   The script skips s6-overlay internal services (s6rc-*,
   s6-linux-*) so the supervision tree itself stays root-only.
   015- slot is intentional: lex-sorts between 01-hermes-setup
   and 02-reconcile-profiles in the container's C-locale, so
   the chown finishes before the reconciler walks the scandir.

Unregister teardown reordering
------------------------------
S6ServiceManager.unregister_profile_gateway now fires
s6-svscanctl -an BEFORE rmtree (with a 200ms grace), so
s6-svscan reaps the supervise child and releases its file
handles on supervise/lock + supervise/status before we try to
remove the directory. Previously rmtree raced s6-supervise on a
set of files inside the supervise dir, and even with the parent
supervise/ now hermes-owned, the contained files (death_tally,
lock, status, written by root) could still be in use.

Dashboard down-state redesign
-----------------------------
The original PR #30136 review fix wrote a 'down' marker file
into /run/service/dashboard/ via cont-init.d/03-dashboard-toggle.
That approach was broken in two ways:

  (a) /run/service/dashboard is a symlink to a TRANSIENT
      /run/s6-rc:s6-rc-init:<tmpdir>/ directory while s6-rc is
      mid-transaction; the touch landed in a soon-to-be-discarded
      tmp.

  (b) Even when written to the final /run/s6-rc/servicedirs/
      location, the 'down' file is only consulted by s6-supervise
      at slot startup. s6-rc's user-bundle explicitly transitions
      'dashboard' to 'up' on every boot, overriding any down
      marker.

The right fix is the canonical s6 pattern: when HERMES_DASHBOARD
is unset, the dashboard run script exits 0 and a companion
finish script exits 125. Per s6-supervise(8), exit code 125 from
the finish script is the 'permanent failure, do not restart'
marker — equivalent to s6-svc -O. The slot reports as 'down' to
s6-svstat, matching the reality that no dashboard process is
running. When HERMES_DASHBOARD IS truthy, finish exits 0 and
restart-on-crash semantics apply.

03-dashboard-toggle is removed (its function is now subsumed by
the run/finish pair).

Tests
-----
Adds four unit tests for _seed_supervise_skeleton covering the
produced layout, the log/ subservice case, the skip-when-no-log
case, and idempotency. The live-container verification continues
to live in tests/docker/test_s6_profile_gateway_integration.py and
tests/docker/test_dashboard.py — both now pass against the
rebuilt image.

References
----------
* Skarnet skaware mailing list 2020-02-02 (Laurent Bercot
  + Guillermo Diaz Hartusch) on unprivileged s6 tool semantics:
  http://skarnet.org/lists/skaware/1424.html
* just-containers/s6-overlay#130 — same EEXIST-preseed pattern,
  community-validated 2016 onward
* https://skarnet.org/software/s6/servicedir.html — exit-code 125
  semantics in finish scripts

(cherry picked from commit c41f908ad4)
This commit is contained in:
Ben
2026-05-25 12:23:23 +10:00
parent 7f6f00f6ec
commit 4f416fc40c
8 changed files with 433 additions and 64 deletions
Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files
hermes_cli/container_boot.py
+12
View File
@@ -193,6 +193,7 @@ def _register_service(scandir: Path, profile: str, *, start: bool) -> None:
from hermes_cli.service_manager import (
S6ServiceManager,
_seed_supervise_skeleton,
validate_profile_name,
)
@@ -232,6 +233,17 @@ def _register_service(scandir: Path, profile: str, *, start: bool) -> None:
if not start:
(tmp_dir / "down").touch()
# Pre-create the supervise/ skeleton with hermes ownership
# BEFORE we publish the slot. Mirrors the same pre-creation
# step in S6ServiceManager.register_profile_gateway — when
# s6-svscan picks the published slot up, the s6-supervise it
# spawns will EEXIST our dirs/FIFOs and inherit hermes
# ownership, so runtime s6-svc / s6-svstat / s6-svwait calls
# (all dispatched as the hermes user) won't hit EACCES. See
# ``_seed_supervise_skeleton`` in service_manager.py for the
# full rationale.
_seed_supervise_skeleton(tmp_dir)
# Publish atomically. Path.replace handles the existing-target
# case the same way os.rename does on POSIX: the target is
# silently replaced, so a previous reconcile pass's slot is
hermes_cli/service_manager.py
+178 -5
View File
@@ -340,6 +340,145 @@ S6_SERVICE_PREFIX = "gateway-"
_S6_BIN_DIR = "/command"
# UID/GID of the in-image ``hermes`` user. Hardcoded to match what
# ``stage2-hook.sh`` enforces (the runtime invariant — see also
# tests/docker/test_uid_remap.py). The container starts s6-supervise
# under root and immediately drops to this UID via ``s6-setuidgid``.
_HERMES_UID = 10000
_HERMES_GID = 10000
def _seed_supervise_skeleton(svc_dir: Path) -> None:
"""Pre-create the ``supervise/`` and top-level ``event/`` skeleton
inside a service directory, owned by the hermes user.
Why this exists
---------------
When s6-supervise spawns a service it tries to ``mkdir`` two
directories: ``<svc>/event`` and ``<svc>/supervise``, both with mode
``0700``. It also ``mkfifo``s ``<svc>/supervise/control`` with mode
``0600``. Because s6-supervise runs as PID 1's effective UID (root)
these dirs end up root-owned mode 0700, and an unprivileged client
(the ``hermes`` user — UID 10000 — running every Hermes runtime
operation via ``s6-setuidgid``) gets ``EACCES`` on any ``s6-svc``,
``s6-svstat``, or ``s6-svwait`` invocation against the slot.
The PR #30136 review surfaced this as a real product gap: the
entire S6ServiceManager lifecycle (``register/start/stop/unregister
_profile_gateway``) was inert in production because every operation
is dispatched as the hermes user.
Why this works
--------------
Reading s6's source (src/supervision/s6-supervise.c::trymkdir +
control_init): the ``mkdir`` and ``mkfifo`` calls both treat
``EEXIST`` as success. If the directory is already present, the
chown/chmod fix-up that would normally make event/ ``03730
root:root`` is **skipped** entirely — s6-supervise just opens the
pre-existing FIFOs and proceeds. So if we lay the skeleton down
with hermes ownership before triggering ``s6-svscanctl -a``,
s6-supervise inherits our layout and never touches it.
Layout produced
---------------
``svc_dir/`` hermes:hermes, 0755 (parent must already exist)
``svc_dir/event/`` hermes:hermes, 03730 (setgid + g+rwx + sticky)
``svc_dir/supervise/`` hermes:hermes, 0755
``svc_dir/supervise/event/`` hermes:hermes, 03730
``svc_dir/supervise/control`` hermes:hermes, 0660 (FIFO)
The ``death_tally``, ``lock``, and ``status`` regular files end up
written by s6-supervise itself (as root), but those land mode 0644 —
world-readable — and ``s6-svstat`` only needs read access, so the
hermes user reads them fine.
If ``svc_dir/log/`` is present (the canonical s6 logger pattern —
one s6-supervise instance per service, plus a second for its
logger), the same skeleton is seeded under ``log/`` as well:
``log/event/``, ``log/supervise/``, ``log/supervise/event/``,
``log/supervise/control``. Without this, unregister teardown
would EACCES on the logger's supervise dir even after the parent
slot's supervise/ was hermes-owned.
Idempotency
-----------
Safe to call against a directory where the skeleton already exists.
Existing entries are left untouched (the helper doesn't try to
re-chown / re-chmod live FIFOs that s6-supervise may have already
opened).
Reference
---------
Discussed at length on the skarnet `skaware` mailing list in 2020
(`<http://skarnet.org/lists/skaware/1424.html>`_); see also
just-containers/s6-overlay#130. The pre-creation pattern was
historically called out as forward-compatibility-fragile, but the
EEXIST handling in s6-supervise has been stable since 2015 — it's
the same pattern ``s6-svperms`` and ``fix-attrs.d`` rely on.
"""
import os
def _mkdir_owned(path: Path, mode: int) -> None:
if path.exists():
return
path.mkdir(parents=False, exist_ok=False)
path.chmod(mode)
try:
os.chown(path, _HERMES_UID, _HERMES_GID)
except PermissionError:
# Running as the hermes user already — directory is hermes-
# owned by default. The chown is a no-op in that case, so
# swallowing this keeps both root and unprivileged callers
# on one code path.
pass
# Top-level event/ dir (this is the s6-svlisten1 event-subscription
# dir at the service root, distinct from supervise/event/).
_mkdir_owned(svc_dir / "event", 0o3730)
# supervise/ dir + its inner event/ dir.
supervise = svc_dir / "supervise"
_mkdir_owned(supervise, 0o755)
_mkdir_owned(supervise / "event", 0o3730)
# supervise/control FIFO. Same EEXIST-safe pattern: if it's already
# there (s6-supervise has already started against this slot), leave
# it alone. The explicit chmod after mkfifo is required because
# mkfifo honors the process umask, which can strip group-write
# (e.g. the default 0022 on most dev hosts → 0o660 becomes 0o640).
# The container runs with umask 0 inside s6-overlay's stage2, but
# being defensive here keeps the helper consistent under any
# invocation context.
control = supervise / "control"
if not control.exists():
os.mkfifo(control, 0o660)
control.chmod(0o660)
try:
os.chown(control, _HERMES_UID, _HERMES_GID)
except PermissionError:
pass
# If a log/ subdir is present (the canonical s6 logger pattern —
# see servicedir(7)), it gets its own s6-supervise instance and
# needs the same skeleton. Without this, unregister teardown
# would EACCES on the logger's root-owned supervise/ dir even
# when the parent slot's supervise/ is hermes-owned.
log_dir = svc_dir / "log"
if log_dir.is_dir():
_mkdir_owned(log_dir / "event", 0o3730)
log_supervise = log_dir / "supervise"
_mkdir_owned(log_supervise, 0o755)
_mkdir_owned(log_supervise / "event", 0o3730)
log_control = log_supervise / "control"
if not log_control.exists():
os.mkfifo(log_control, 0o660)
log_control.chmod(0o660)
try:
os.chown(log_control, _HERMES_UID, _HERMES_GID)
except PermissionError:
pass
class S6Error(RuntimeError):
"""Base error for S6ServiceManager lifecycle failures.
@@ -636,6 +775,15 @@ class S6ServiceManager:
log_run.write_text(self._render_log_run(profile))
log_run.chmod(0o755)
# Pre-create the supervise/ skeleton with hermes ownership
# BEFORE we publish the slot. s6-supervise will EEXIST our
# dirs/FIFOs and inherit the ownership, so the runtime
# s6-svc / s6-svstat / s6-svwait calls (all dispatched as
# the hermes user) won't hit EACCES on root-owned 0700
# dirs. See ``_seed_supervise_skeleton`` for the full
# rationale.
_seed_supervise_skeleton(tmp_dir)
tmp_dir.rename(svc_dir)
except Exception:
shutil.rmtree(tmp_dir, ignore_errors=True)
@@ -661,9 +809,18 @@ class S6ServiceManager:
wait-for-down before removal so the running gateway process
gets a chance to shut down cleanly before its service dir
disappears.
Teardown ordering matters: ``s6-svscanctl -an`` is fired
**before** ``rmtree`` so s6-svscan reaps the supervise child
process (releasing its handle on ``supervise/lock`` and the
regular files inside the supervise dir), giving us a clean
directory to remove. Without the reap-first ordering, the
rmtree races s6-supervise on a set of root-owned files inside
the supervise dir and the dir is left half-removed.
"""
import shutil
import subprocess
import time
svc_dir = self._service_dir(profile)
if not svc_dir.exists():
@@ -682,16 +839,32 @@ class S6ServiceManager:
check=False,
)
# Remove the directory.
shutil.rmtree(svc_dir, ignore_errors=True)
# Rescan so s6-svscan drops its supervise process for the dir.
# -n = also reap orphan supervise processes.
# Reap the supervise child FIRST: -n tells s6-svscan to drop
# any supervise processes whose service dir is gone (which
# includes any service dir we're about to remove). This
# releases the file handles s6-supervise holds against the
# supervise/lock + supervise/status + supervise/death_tally
# files inside the slot, so the upcoming rmtree doesn't race.
subprocess.run(
[f"{_S6_BIN_DIR}/s6-svscanctl", "-an", str(self.scandir)],
capture_output=True, text=True, timeout=5,
check=False,
)
# Give s6-svscan a moment to reap. There's no synchronous
# "scan completed" handshake — the -a/-n trigger just sets a
# flag s6-svscan reads on its next loop iteration. 200ms is
# comfortably above the loop's resolution but well under any
# user-perceived latency.
time.sleep(0.2)
# Now the supervise dir's files are no longer held open by a
# live s6-supervise, so rmtree can remove them. Files inside
# supervise/ are root-owned (death_tally, lock, status, written
# by s6-supervise itself) — but the parent supervise/ directory
# is hermes-owned (see ``_seed_supervise_skeleton``), and on
# POSIX you only need write+execute on the parent to remove
# contained files regardless of file ownership.
shutil.rmtree(svc_dir, ignore_errors=True)
def list_profile_gateways(self) -> list[str]:
"""Return the profile names of all currently-registered gateway services.